Event Details


Title:Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-824, July 8, 1999
Micro summary:This Boeing 737-824 experienced clear air turbulence in cruise, injuring several people.
Event Time:1999-07-08 at 1410 EDT
File Name:1999-07-08-US.pdf
Publishing Agency:National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
Publishing Country:USA
Report number:IAD99FA052
Pages:8
Diversion Airport:Bermuda International Airport, Ferry Reach, Bermuda
Site of event:Atlantic Ocean, AO
Departure:Newark Liberty International Airport, Newark & Elizabeth, New Jersey, USA
Destination:Luis Muoz Mar’n International Airport, San Juan, Puerto Rico
Airplane Type(s):Boeing 737-824
Flight Phase:Cruise
Registration(s):N12221
Operator(s):Continental Airlines
Type of flight:Revenue
Occupants:161
Fatalities:0
Serious Injuries:1
Minor/Non-Injured:160
Other Injuries:0
Diverted to:Bermuda International Airport, Ferry Reach, Bermuda
Executive Summary:

NTSB short summary:

the aircrew's inadvertent encounter with unforecast clear air turbulence.

NTSB synopsis:

The airplane was in cruise flight at 29,000 feet in smooth air with the seat belt sign turned off. The crew reported two jolts, and the airplane descended 600 feet. Due to possible injuries, the crew diverted to Bermuda (BDA) and landed. Readout of the flight data recorder indicated cruise flight at 29,000 feet with no change in heading, airspeed, or altitude for several minutes approaching the accident sequence. The altitude graph showed a slight climb before the airplane descended to 28,400 feet. The graph line indicated a slow recovery to 29,000 feet with no oscillations. The elapsed time between the first altitude excursion to recovered cruise flight was approximately 75 seconds. Of the 155 passengers on board, one passenger received serious injuries and 67 received minor injuries. The flight was scheduled for Flight Level 330 to Flight Level 370. Therefore, no information concerning forecast turbulence at Flight Level 290 was available to the flight crew. The High Level Significant Weather Prognosis chart for that period revealed that no significant weather was shown in the area where the turbulence was encountered.

NTSB factual narrative text:

HISTORY OF FLIGHT

On July 8, 1999 at 1410 eastern daylight time, a Boeing 737-824, N12221, operated by Continental Airlines, sustained minor damage during a clear air turbulence encounter, while in cruise flight at 29,000 feet, approximately 180 miles south of Bermuda. The airline transport rated flight crew was not injured and the four cabin attendants received minor injuries. Of the 155 passengers on board, one passenger received serious injuries, 67 received minor injuries and 87 passengers were not injured. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed for the scheduled passenger flight that originated at Newark, New Jersey (EWR), approximately 1220. An instrument flight rules flight plan was filed for the flight destined for San Juan, Puerto Rico, and conducted under 14 CFR Part 121.

In a telephone interview, a safety official for Continental Airlines reported the airplane was in cruise flight at 29,000 feet in smooth air with the seat belt sign turned off. He said the crew reported one jolt, and the airplane descended 500 feet. Due to possible injuries, the crew diverted to Bermuda (BDA) and landed at 1604.

In a written statement, the captain said:

"Approximately ten miles north of Pruit intersection on A523 at 29,000 ft. in clear air we encountered two severe jolts (turbulence). Our aircraft lost approximately 400 ft. and was descending at 2,000 ft. per minute. Speed was approaching MMO (Maximum Mach Operating Speed). I made a slow recovery back to 29,000, bottoming out our descent at 28,400. The seat belt sign was off and during recovery I placed it back on. When the aircraft was level we attempted to reach the flight attendants via the inter-phone, no response. I instructed my F.O. (First Officer) to go into the cabin and assess damages. He quickly informed me of numerous injuries, at that time I declared an emergency and diverted to Bermuda. Turning direct to BDA our location was 160 miles SSW...No reports of turbulence were reported by ATC (Air Traffic Control) along our route of flight or in our dispatched flight paper work."

In a written statement, the first officer said:

"We were level at FL 290 [29,000 feet]...It had been smooth for 30 minutes [and] the seat belt sign was off, there were no visual cues to an adverse ride. Both radars were on (we had deviated to avoid weather earlier in the flight) when the aircraft was hit by two severe jolts in quick succession. The Captain (Pilot Flying) recovered the aircraft from a nose down attitude, when the aircraft was once again level and on course the autopilot, L [lateral] nav and V [vertical] nav were re-selected."

In a written statement, a cabin attendant said:

"The crew had just completed the meal service and I was in the back of ...the main cabin approximately row 29 picking up trays from the meal service. The seat belt sign was off and we were flying through smooth air with no sign of turbulence. Then all of a sudden, the aircraft dropped abruptly, which caused my body to fly upward hitting my head on the ceiling. I fell back to the floor on my knees. Approximately 10 seconds later, the aircraft dropped again causing my head to hit the ceiling once again. At that point I lost consciousness. When I awoke, I was very dazed noticing my head bleeding, arms cut and bruised, and back and shoulders sore."

In a detailed written statement, a second cabin attendant described a similar sequence of events. She said people, carts, and equipment were tossed about and that she came to rest under a row of seats. The cabin attendant further described the crew coordination involved in treating and calming the passengers and the communication from the cockpit to the cabin about the egress and treatment of passengers upon arrival at Bermuda.

The captain arranged through ATC to have medical teams meet the airplane at BDA. Sixty-four passengers and 4 cabin attendants were examined at the hospital. One passenger suffered a head laceration and a fractured rib.

The accident occurred during the hours of daylight approximately 30 degrees 20 minutes north latitude, 066 degrees 43 minutes west longitude.

PILOT INFORMATION

The captain held an airline transport pilot's certificate with ratings for airplane multi-engine land. He held a commercial pilot's certificate with ratings for airplane single-engine land, rotorcraft helicopter and instrument helicopter. The captain held a flight instructor's certificate with ratings for airplane single-engine land and a mechanic's certificate with ratings for airframe and powerplant.

The captain's most recent FAA first class medical certificate was issued June 8, 1999.

The captain reported 14,800 hours of flight experience, 3,300 hours of which were in the Boeing 737. He reported 215 hours of flight experience in the previous 90 days, 76 hours of which were in the previous 30 days. All flight time reported in the previous 90 days was in the Boeing 737.

The first officer held an airline transport pilot's certificate with ratings for airplane multi-engine land. He held a commercial pilot's certificate with ratings for airplane single-engine land. The first officer held a flight engineer's certificate with a rating for turbojet powered.

The first officer's most recent FAA first class medical certificate was issued May 24, 1999.

The first officer reported 10,000 hours of total flight experience, 5,000 hours of which were in the Boeing 737. He reported 203 hours of flight experience in the previous 90 days, 18 hours of which were in the previous 30 days. All flight time reported in the previous 90 days was in the Boeing 737.

DAMAGE TO AIRCRAFT

Inspection of the airplane revealed no structural damage and the airplane was returned to service. Entries in the airplane's maintenance log reflected completion of the turbulence inspection and damage to interior ceiling panels in Row 25, 29, and in the aft galley.

AIRCRAFT INFORMATION

The airplane was a 1998 Boeing 737-824, and the airworthiness certificate was issued December 2, 1998. The airplane was on a continuous airworthiness inspection program and had accrued 3,639 hours of total flight time. The last inspection was performed July 3, 1999, and the airplane accrued 51 hours of flight time since that date.

METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION

A Safety Board Operational Factors investigator interviewed the captain by telephone. According to the interview summary:

"[The captain] stated that the flight departed Newark on schedule. The flight encountered weather at cruise altitude near KWINN intersection, about 300 miles north of the point where the turbulence encounter occurred. Clearance was requested by the flight crew and approved by air traffic control to deviate around the weather. The seatbelt sign was on.

"The flight proceeded around the thunderstorms and broke out into the clear with only some high clouds visible. [The captain] stated that the ride was 'not all that bad' and this was the 'only major weather we saw.' For about 45 minutes before the turbulence encounter, the ride was smooth. The seatbelt sign was turned off during this time.

"At the time of the turbulence encounter, the flight was in contact with New York Center via the VHF radio. [The captain] stated that there were two 'major jolts that came out of nowhere.' The flight attendants were called on the interphone but there was no answer. [The captain] then sent the first officer to the cabin to assess the situation.

"[The captain] said that Continental Airlines uses a 'shear rating indicator' to estimate the degree of turbulence that is anticipated along the route of flight. The shear rating indicator (SR) is shown on the flight plan and expressed as a number from zero to five, with five indicating the worst turbulence. During the first part of the flight, twos and threes were shown along the flight-planned route. Starting about GABES intersection, the SR was zero. The SR at PRUIT intersection was zero. [The captain] stated that 'nothing else indicated severe turbulence; no other ride reports; the sky was wide open.' [The captain] stated that he made a conscious effort to change the route about KWINN intersection to get around the weather to the east and to get into smooth air. At PRUIT intersection, he stated that they were in the clear with high clouds in view to the west. There were no towering cumulus clouds, nothing to indicate the existence of turbulence."

According to flight papers, the flight altitude was planned for FL 330 to FL 370. Therefore, no information concerning forecast turbulence at FL 290 was available to the flight crew.

The High Level Significant Weather Prognosis chart prepared by the Aviation Weather Center (AWC) at Kansas City, Missouri, valid for 1400, revealed that no significant weather was shown in the area where the turbulence was encountered.

FLIGHT RECORDERS

The airplane's flight data recorder (FDR) was forwarded to the Safety Board for examination. Examination of the data retrieved revealed a sequence of events consistent with that described in the crew statements.

A graph of several flight parameters indicated cruise flight at 29,000 feet with no change in heading, airspeed, or altitude for several minutes approaching the accident sequence. The altitude graph showed a slight climb before the airplane descended to 28,400 feet. The graph line indicated a slow recovery to 29,000 feet with no oscillations. Vertical g-forces sustained during the sequence varied in amplitude between a positive 2-g's and a negative 1-g. The elapsed time between the first altitude excursion to recovered cruise flight was approximately 75 seconds.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

The airplane was returned to service by Continental Airlines on July 9, 1999.
Learning Keywords:Operations - Turbulence
Consequence - Flight Attendant Fatality - Injury
Close match:Turbulence, Report on the accident to Airbus A330-342 B-HYA within the Manila Flight Information Region on 18 July 2003
Accident involving turbulence and Aer Arann ATR-42-300 on descent to Donegal International Airport, Ireland, on December 2, 2001
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 747-443, G-VROM
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 777-236, G-VIIO
Turbulence injuries, Airbus A300B4-605R, G-MONR
Severe turbulence, Boeing 777-236, G-YMME
Turbulence, Boeing 747-436, G-CIVP
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 777-200, N786UA
Turbulence injury, Boeing 777, April 25, 2006
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-223, June 5, 2005
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-700, April 29, 2005
Turbulence injury, Boeing 767-232, September 29, 2004
Turbulence injury, Boeing 777, July 25, 2004
Turbulence injury, Airbus A319, July 17, 2004
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, July 15, 2004
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-7H4, June 4, 2004
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, May 26, 2004
Turbulence injury, Boeing 767-300, April 10, 2004
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-200, March 1, 2004
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-500, November 1, 2003
Turbulence injuries, Pan American World Airways, Inc., Boeing 747-121, N739PA, near Nantucket, Massachusetts, November 4, 1970
Turbulence, Northwest Airlines, Inc., Boeing 747-151, N606US, Over the North Pacific Ocean, 105 Nautical Miles West of 150° East Longitude at 36° North Latitude, April 12, 1972
Turbulence injuries, National Airlines, Inc., Boeing 747-135, N77772, Near Lake Charles, Louisiana, January 4, 1972
Turbulence injuries, Air France, Boeing 707-B-328B, F-BLCA, Near O-Neill, Nebraska, May 13, 1974
Turbulence injuries, Air Canada Flight 965, Lockheed L-1011, C-FTNJ, Near Charleston, South Carolina, November 24, 1983
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-232, September 15, 1993
Turbulence injury, Boeing 747-400, February 12, 1994
Turbulence on descent involving a Boeing 737-790, near Anchroage, Alaska, on November 13, 2000
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-400, December 22, 1996
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 727-200, July 28, 2000
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-200, April 17, 2001
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-200, May 29, 2002
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, November 6, 2002
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 727-200, March 16, 1995
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-200, April 28, 1997
Turbulence injuries, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-80, February 8, 1999
Turbulence injury, Boeing 777-223, August 22, 2000
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 757-200, April 18, 2002
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 757-222, April 21, 2003
Turbulence injury, Airbus A319-111, June 2, 2003
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 777-222, June 11, 1999
Turbulence injuries, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-81, August 7, 2003
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-201, June 22, 1996
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 767-222, June 20, 1995
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 757, August 4, 1995
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-51, January 28, 1997
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 747-422, September 14, 1997
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 767-223, July 22, 1998
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-222, May 5, 1999
Turbulence injuries, McDonnell Douglas DC-10-30, March 22, 2002
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-2B7, May 24, 1998
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-3H4, June 25, 1999
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-223, April 7, 1996
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-2G7, January 11, 2000
Turbulence Injury, Boeing 757-2G7, April 2, 2000
Turbulence injury, Airbus A320-232, April 19, 2001
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-500, August 9, 2001
Turbulence injury, Boeing 747-422, May 1, 2002
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas MD-82, June 12, 2003
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 747-422, October 17, 1995
Turbulence injury, Boeing 747-122, November 1, 1995
Turbulence injury, Boeing 747-422, November 19, 1996
Turbulence injury, December 22, 1996
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 737-242C, March 4, 1998
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-300, December 13, 1998
Turbulence on descent, Airbus A320-231, September 16, 1999
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 767-332ER, September 20, 2000
Turbulence injury, Boeing 757-2G7, May 28, 2001
Turbulence injury, Airbus A320-232, August 20, 2001
Turbulence on descent, Boeing 777-223, February 25, 2003
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas MD-88, Janaury 6, 1995
Turbulence injury, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, October 1, 1997
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-724, February 19, 2002
Turbulence injury, Boeing 767-224, April 22, 2002
Turbulence injury, Boeing 767-300, May 7, 2003
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-800, August 16, 2003
Turbulence injury, Airbus A300B4-605R, January 7, 1997
Turbulence injury, Boeing 747-200, April 18, 1998
Turbulence injury, Bombardier DHC-8-102, September 27, 1998
Turbulence injury, September 30, 1999
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 767-332ER, November 4, 2000
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-522, November 25, 1995
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-2H4, July 7, 1994
Turbulence injury, Boeing 737-291A, June 11, 1997
Tubulence, December 28, 1997, Boeing 747-122, December 28, 1997
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 777-236, G-VIIP, May 14, 2006
Turbulence injuries, Airbus A340-300, D-AIGK, September 18, 1996
Turbulence injuries, Boeing 757-2Q8, N755AT, March 2, 1997
Turbulence injuries, Airbus A340-300, D-AIGK, August 6, 2003

 




Accident Reports on DVD, Copyright © 2006 by Flight Simulation Systems, LLC.  All Rights Reserved.
 All referenced trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
www.fss.aero