Event Details


Title:Boeing 757 slide loss on climbout from Seattle, October 16, 1997
Micro summary:On rotation, an overwing slide detached and fell off.
Event Time:1997-10-16 at 830 PDT
File Name:1997-10-16-US.pdf
Publishing Agency:National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
Publishing Country:USA
Report number:FTW98IA019
Pages:6
Diversion Airport:Denver International Airport, Denver, Colorado, USA
Site of event:Seattle, WA
Departure:Seattle-Tacoma International Airport, Seattle, Washington, USA
Destination:Denver International Airport, Denver, Colorado, USA
Airplane Type(s):Boeing 757-222
Flight Phase:Takeoff
Registration(s):N581UA
Operator(s):United Airlines
Type of flight:Revenue
Occupants:196
Fatalities:0
Serious Injuries:0
Minor/Non-Injured:196
Other Injuries:0
Diverted to:Denver International Airport, Denver, Colorado, USA
Executive Summary:

NTSB short summary:

Maintenance personnel's failure to properly secure the left off-wing slide door after routine slide replacement, allowing an inflight separation of the slide. Factors were inadequate training of maintenance personnel and inadequate written instructions by the airplane manufacturer.

NTSB synopsis:

As the airplane was rotated for liftoff from Seattle, the captain noticed that the EICAS (engine indication and crew alerting system) 'EMERGENCY DOOR' light had illuminated. According to the Airplane Fight Manual, if pressurization is normal (and it was), the crew need not take further action. During the descent for landing, a flight attendant said she heard a loud noise from the left side of the airplane. The airplane landed uneventfully at Denver. Inspection disclosed the left off-wing slide had separated from the airplane, causing minor damage to the access door, flap, and fuselage skin. The slide had been routinely replaced the previous evening by a mechanic using a flashlight and referencing the airplane maintenance manuals. After installing the slide, the mechanic closed the panel and placed the actuator handle in the horizontal position (as per instructions placarded on the maintenance access door). He said he had never received any training for installing the off-wing slide. There have been four similar incidents since the airplane entered commercial service, prompting the manufacturer to issue Service Bulletin (S.B.) 757-25-0182.

NTSB factual narrative text:

HISTORY OF FLIGHT

On October 16, 1997, between 0830 Pacific daylight time and 1127 mountain daylight time, a Boeing 757-222, N581UA, owned and operated by United Airlines, Inc., sustained minor damage when the left off-wing evacuation slide separated from the airplane during its flight from Seattle, Washington, to Denver, Colorado. There were no injuries to the airline transport-rated captain, airline transport-rated first officer, 6 flight attendants, and 188 passengers. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and an IFR flight plan had been filed. The airplane was being operated as Flight 724 in scheduled domestic passenger service under Title 14 CFR Part 121 when the incident occurred. The flight departed Seattle at 0830.

The first officer was flying the airplane. As the airplane was rotated for liftoff, the captain noticed that the EICAS (engine indication and crew alerting system) "EMERGENCY DOOR" light had illuminated. According to United's Boeing 757/767 Flight Manual, if pressurization is normal --- and it was --- the crew need not take further action. During the descent for landing, a flight attendant said she heard a loud noise from the left side of the airplane. The airplane landed uneventfully at Denver at 1127.

DAMAGE TO AIRCRAFT

Postincident inspection disclosed the left off-wing slide had separated from the airplane. The slide was never recovered. There was a 1-1/2 inch tear in the left inboard flap near the trailing edge, a 1-inch tear in the evacuation slide access door, a 9-inch horizontal tear in the honeycomb fillet panel, and a 20-inch tear in the fuselage skin between F.S. (fuselage station) 1420 and 1440. Repair costs were estimated at $75,000.

AIRCRAFT INFORMATION

According to United Airlines, there had been a routine replacement of the left off-wing evacuation slide on the evening before the incident. One of two mechanics involved in replacing the slide was interviewed on November 4, 1997. The mechanic, a 12-year veteran with United, said this was the second time he had replaced the off-wing slide, the first time occurring some 10 years before. The replacement was made during the hours of darkness, using a flashlight and referencing Boeing 757 Maintenance Manuals 25-65-00 and 25-65-01. After installing the slide, he closed the panel and, following the instructions placarded on the maintenance access door, placed the actuator handle in the horizontal position. He said he had never received any training for installing the off-wing slide.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

In a meeting with Boeing officials that same day, it was revealed that since the airplane entered service in November 1984, there had been four other incidents similar to that involving N581UA. The first incident also involved United Airlines and occurred on June 8, 1993, in Los Angeles California. The incident was investigated by NTSB's Southwest Regional Office (see LAX 93-I-A245). The second incident occurred on September 23, 1995, at Newark, New Jersey, and involved Continental Airlines. On rotation for liftoff, the EICAS illuminated. The flight continued to Houston, Texas. After landing, it was discovered that the right overwing slide had deployed and was hanging off the right wing. The third incident occurred on November 15, 1995, during a test flight at Everett, Washington. The airplane involved was scheduled to be delivered to Northwest Airlines. The last incident occurred on June 24, 1997, at Dallas-Fort Worth, Texas, and involved American Airlines. The Emergency Doors EICAS light illuminated shortly after takeoff. The airplane returned and landed uneventfully. American Airlines officials said the slide had hung in the slipstream for approximately 10 seconds before separating, causing a discernible airframe vibration.

As a result of these incidents, Boeing issued Service Bulletin (S.B.) 757-25-0182, dated October 10, 1996, and revised it on June 12, 1997. It calls for the replacement of the lockbase retainer and the bearing for the door latch tube, and relocating the door sensor to a forward position on the slide compartment door to enable a more positive indication that the slide compartment door is latched.
Learning Keywords:Operations - Maintenance
Consequence - Damage - Airframe or fuselage
Close match:Uncontained engine failure, Aircraft Accident Report, Garuda Indonesia Flight GA 880, Boeing B747-200 PK-GSD, In flight (21 minutes after takeoff from Denpasar, Bali), 23 November 2001
Uncontained Engine Failure, Aircraft Incident Report, Japan Airlines Flight JL726, B747-300 JA8178, Tangerang, West Java, Indonesia, 5 September 2000
Access door loss and fuselage damage, Boeing 777-236B, G-VIIA
Explosive decompression on climb, Report on the accident to BAC One-Eleven, G-BJRT over Didcot, Oxfordshire on 10 June 1990
Loss of overwing slide, Boeing 747SP-100, N204 AE
In-flight Breakup Over The Atlantic Ocean, Trans World Airlines Flight 800, Boeing 747-131, N93119, Near East Moriches, New York, July 17, 1996
In-Flight Engine Separation, Japan Airlines, Inc., Flight 46E, Boeing 747-121, N473EV, Anchorage, Alaska, March 31, 1993
Structural failure, Aloha Airlines, Flight 243, Boeing 737-200, N73711, Near Maui, Hawaii, April 28, 1988
Uncontained engine failure, Northwest Airlines, Inc., Boeing 747-151, N607US, Honolulu, Hawaii, May 13, 1971
Engine failure, National Airlines, Inc., McDonnell-Douglas DC-10-10, N60NA, Near Tampa, Florida, July 8, 1974
Uncontained engine failure, Eastern Airlines Flight 935 Lockheed L-1011-385, N309EA Near Colts Neck, New Jersey September 22, 1981
Tailcone loss in climb, Air Canada, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-32 (CF-TLU), East Of Boston, Massachusetts, September 17, 1979
Engine failure and evacuation, Airbus A319, November 2, 2001
Uncommanded roll, McDonnell Douglas MD-11F, June 2, 2002
Uncontained engine failure, McDonnell Douglas MD-83, June 17, 1997
Uncontained engine failure, Douglas DC-9-32, March 18, 1997
Uncontained engine failure, McDonnell Douglas MD-82, November 23, 1996
Uncontained engine failure, Douglas DC-9-32, May 5, 1994
Uncontained engine failure, Boeing 727-224, October 7, 1998
Uncontained engine failure, Boeing 737-200, April 28, 1997
Wheels-up landing, Douglas DC-8-71F, April 26, 2001
Separation of engine cowling, Douglas DC-8-62F, April 27, 2000
Runway excursion, Boeing 737-223, Atlanta, November 1, 1998
Massive tire failure following gear retract cylinder support frame failure, McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10, August 10, 2002
Landing gear collapse on landing, Douglas DC-9-31, June 3, 2002
Loss of engine cowlings, Douglas DC-8-63F, February 19, 2000
Landing gear collapse on landing, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, Denver, April 27, 1993
Failure of nose gear actuator and loss of pressurization, McDonnell Douglas MD-88, May 13, 2005
Fan cowling separation resulting in horizontal stabilizer damage, Airbus A320-232, June 12, 2000
Failure of left main landing gear outboard axle, Boeing 737-200, October 4, 1997
Foreign object damage to both engines, Boeing 737-200, March 20, 1996
Damage in cruise from partially detached thrust reverser, Douglas DC-9-31, October 13, 1995
Aircraft Accident Report, Explosive Decompression — Loss of cargo door in flight, United Airlines Flight 811, Boeing 747-122, N4713U, Honolulu, Hawaii, February 24, 1989
Uncontained engine failure, Boeing 707-341, N107BV, August 2, 1993
Uncontained engine failure, Boeing 747-240, AP-BAK, December 6, 1995
Tire shred on takeoff, Airbus A340-300, C-FYKX, August 18, 2003

 




Accident Reports on DVD, Copyright © 2006 by Flight Simulation Systems, LLC.  All Rights Reserved.
 All referenced trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
www.fss.aero