Event Details


Title:Clogged fuel filter, Airbus A320, February 16, 1998
Micro summary:This Airbus A320 diverted after the ECAM indicated there was a clogged #1 fuel filter.
Event Time:1998-02-16 at 1240 CST
File Name:1998-02-16-US.pdf
Publishing Agency:National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
Publishing Country:USA
Report number:CHI98IA095
Pages:6
Diversion Airport:Memphis International Airport, Memphis, Tennessee, USA
Site of event:Memphis, TN
Departure:Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport, Romulus, Michigan, USA
Destination:Lic. Benito Ju‡rez International Airport, Mexico City, Distrito Federal, Mexico
Airplane Type(s):Airbus A320-212
Flight Phase:Cruise
Registration(s):N341NW
Operator(s):Northwest Airlines
Type of flight:Revenue
Occupants:117
Fatalities:0
Serious Injuries:0
Minor/Non-Injured:117
Other Injuries:0
Diverted to:Memphis International Airport, Memphis, Tennessee, USA
Executive Summary:

NTSB short summary:

the inadequate (bronze) material used by the fuel pump's manufacturer, which wore and ultimately blocked the fuel filter bypass and partially blocked the fuel nozzles, causing the fuel spray to burn through the low pressure turbine case.

NTSB synopsis:

While en route from Detroit to Mexico City , the flightcrew received a warning message from the Engine Condition and Monitoring System (ECAS) that the No. 1 fuel filter was clogged. The flight was subsequently diverted to Memphis for a precautionary landing. Post-landing examination of the engine revealed a 4-inch long (circumferential) by 1-inch wide (axial) burn-through in the low pressure turbine case in the plane of the 2nd stage turbine stators at the 11 o'clock location. The examination of the fuel pump filter revealed the presence of a bronze-colored material. The fuel nozzles were reported to have bronze-colored material in the nozzle jets. Records show that the fuel pump had operated 17,208 hours time since new and 6,972 cycles since new. The disassembly of the pump revealed the pump housing had gear pocket milling. The fixed and driven bearings, which are made of bronze, were worn. The fuel pump's filter bypass valve was found to have bronze-colored particles on both sides of the valve. The fuel pump's four bearings were made of bronze and all four bearings exhibited wear and material loss.

NTSB factual narrative text:

On February 16, 1998, at 1240 central standard time, an Airbus A-320-212, N341NW, operated by Northwest Airlines, had an Engine Condition and Monitoring System (ECAMS) No. 1 fuel filter clog warning message about 200 miles from Memphis, Tennessee. The flight crew decided to divert the aircraft to Memphis, Tennessee. While turning inbound on the first turn in holding at 10,000 feet msl to burn off fuel to get down to the maximum landing weight, the No. 1 CFM56-5A3 turbofan engine experienced an uncommanded in-flight shutdown. The attempt to restart the engine was unsuccessful. An uneventful single-engine landing was made. There were no injuries to the captain or first officer, the five flight attendants, or the 110 passengers. The 14 CFR Part 121, Flight 1821, had departed Detroit Metropolitan Airport, Detroit, Michigan, en route to Mexico City, Mexico. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed and the flight was on an instrument flight plan.

The examination of the engine revealed a 4-inch long (circumferential) by 1-inch wide (axial) burn-through in the low pressure turbine case in the plane of the 2nd stage turbine stators at the 11 o'clock location. There was reported heat distress to the left engine pylon. The examination of the fuel pump filter revealed the presence of a bronze-colored material. The fuel nozzles were partially blocked by bronze-colored material in the nozzle jets.

The engine was removed from the airplane and shipped to SNECMA, where it was disassembled under the direction of the Bureau Enquetes Accidents. The engine was equipped with an Argo-Tech fuel pump, part number (PN) 714900-2. The fuel pump was removed from the engine and returned to Argo-Tech Corporation, Cleveland, Ohio, for disassembly and examination.

Northwest Airlines records show that the fuel pump, PN 714900-2, serial number (SN) 37001, had operated 17,208 hours time since new (TSN) and 6,972 cycles since new (CSN). The records show that the fuel pump had not been removed from the engine, SN 731-709, since the engine had been received by Northwest Airlines. The engine's records show that it had operated 17,208 hours TSN and 6,972 CSN.

The disassembly and examination of the fuel pump revealed the pump housing had gear pocket milling. The fixed and pressurized bearings, which are made of bronze, were worn. The fuel pump's filter bypass valve was found to have bronze-colored particles on both sides of the valve.

The drive and driven gears were both intact. The teeth of the driven gear were worn approximately 0.017 inches diametrically. The drive and driven gear were measured and compared to new parts as follows:

Feature New part dimension Actual dimension

Drive gear OD 3.2474-3.2480 inches 3.248 inches

Driven gear OD 3.2474-3.2480 3.231

The pump gear housing had gear pocket milling on the driven gear side. The housing was sectioned at the milled area and a measurement of the remaining wall thickness showed that it was 0.240-inches thick. The driven gear had wear that corresponded to wear on the quad-ring bolt bosses inside the housing. The remaining wall thickness at the quad-ring bolt boss was found to be 0.450 inches.

The fuel pump has four bearings: the fixed drive bearing, fixed driven bearing, pressurized drive bearing, and pressurized driven bearing, which are made of bronze. The fixed bearings did not move freely and were slightly recessed below the split line. All four bearings exhibited wear and material loss. The bearings from the pump were weighed for comparison to new bearings.

Part New part weight Actual weight

Fixed drive bearing 623.42 grams 623.7 grams

Fixed driven bearing 622.86 564.4

Pressurized drive bearing 602.13 570.2

Pressurized driven bearing 603.45 493.8

The fixed drive bearing had a dam wipe of 0.041 inches. The bearing face had minor scoring. The bearing bore was in good condition. The rear side of the bearing did not show any wear.

The fixed driven bearing had a severe dam wipe. The face of the bearing was worn. The bearing bore was worn 0.146 inches. The back side of the bearing was not worn.

The pressurized drive bearing had a severe dam wipe. The face of the bearing was worn. The bearing bore was scored.

The pressurized driven bearing had a severe dam wipe. The face of the bearing was worn. The bearing bore was worn 0.146 inches. The "O" ring and backup ring on the pressurized driven bearing were found to be cut and the "O" ring was also nibbled. (See NTSB Powerplants Group Chairman's Factual Report)

The fuel control, or hydro-mechanical unit (HMU), was inspected. The examination revealed no anomalies to the HMU that contributed to the main fuel pump failure. (See Woodward Governor Engineering Analytical Report)

Parties to the investigation included the Federal Aviation Administration, Northwest Airlines, GE Aircraft Engines, CFM International, Argo-Tech, SNECMA, and Woodward Governor Company.
Learning Keywords:Systems - Engine - Contained Engine Failure
Close match:Engine failure on takeoff, Accident, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-41, SE-DOM
Flat spin, Accident occurredon 25 June 1997 to Aircraft SUKHOI 26M, registration RA01295, in Barberá del Valles (Barcelona)
Runway overrun, Serious incident occurring January 19, 2004 at Frankfurt-Hahn involving a DC-10-40F
Engine vibration, Accident occurring 5 January 2004 near Munich Airport involving a Fokker F28 Mk0070 (Fokker 70)
Apparent engine failure after takeoff, Accident involving aircraft SE-GOP at Optand airport, Z county, Sweden, on 6 August 2004
Engine failure, Aircraft incident at Kajaani airport, Finland 1. October 1996
Engine damage at Helsinki-Vantaa Airport on 17th October, 2000
Birdstrike on B757-200, N34131, at Shannon Airport, 20 May 2005
Runway excursion on landing involving a Boeing 747-136, G-AWNN at Shannon Airport, on 24 October 1998
Engine failure, Serious Incident to ATR 42 EI-CBK near Dublin 8 August 2003
Birdstrike on takeoff, Boeing 737-204 (ADV) (EI-CJH), Dublin, Ireland, April 19, 2003
Multiple system failures, Airbus A340-642, G-VATL
Loss of oil on climb on both engines, Boeing 737-400, G-OBMM
Crash short of runway, Boeing 737-400, British Midlands, G-OBME at Nottingham East Midlands Airport
Report on the accident to Aerospatiale AS332L Super Puma, G-TIGK, in North Sea 6 nm South West of Brae Alpha Oil Production Platform on 19 January 1995
Oil filter clog, Airbus A300-600, N70072
Engine damage in climb, Boeing 747-236B, G-BDXH, 21 May 1996
Grinding sound on takeoff, Boeing 727-230F, OO-DHY
Engine vibration on climb, Airbus A321-211, F-GTAF
Engine vibration on approach, Airbus A321-231, G-OJEG
Contained engine failure and rejected takeoff, Boeing 747-236B, G-BDXO, 14 October 1996
Gear deployment problems, McDonnell Douglas MD-88, TC-ONM
Engine fire, McDonnell Douglas DC-10-30, N68065
Total engine oil loss, Boeing 767-336, G-BNWT
Engine failure on takeoff, Boeing 777-200, G-VIIH, 12 March 1998 at 1900 hrs
Engine failure, BAe 146-200, G-JEAR
Engine failure, McDonnell-Douglas DC10-30ER, C-GCPH
Birdstrike and engine failure on takeoff, Boeing 767-336, G-BNWM
Bang! on gear retraction, Boeing 737-236, G-BGDL
Engine failure on takeoff, Boeing 747-436, G-BNLG
Airframe vibration during climb, Boeing 747-367, AP-BFY
In-Flight Engine Failure and Subsequent Ditching, Air Sunshine, Inc., Flight 527, Cessna 402C, N314AB, About 7.35 Nautical Miles West-Northwest of Treasure Cay Airport, Great Abaco Island, Bahamas, July 13, 2003
In-flight loss of both engines, McDonnell Douglas MD-82, June 4, 2002
Inadvertent evacuation involving a parked Boeing 737-500 at Eugene Airport, Eugene Oregon, on December 25, 1997
Uncontained Engine Failure, Delta Air Lines Flight 1288, McDonnell Douglas MD-88, N927DA, Pensacola, Florida, July 6, 1996
Engine failure, Air France, Boeing 747-128, F-BPVD, St. Jean, P.Q., Canada, August 17, 1970
Crash after takeoff, United Air Lines, Inc., Boeing 737-222, N9005U, Philadelphia International Airport, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 19, 1970
Multiple engine failure, Eastern Air Lines, Inc., Lockheed L-1011, N334EA, Miami International Airport, Miami, Florida, May 5, 1983
Crash following engine failure, Southern Airways, Inc., DC-9-31, N1335U, New Hope, Georgia, April 4, 1977
Power loss in thunderstorm, Air Wisconsin, Swearingen SA-226 Metro, N650S, Valley, Nebraska, June 12, 1980
Contained engine failure on a Douglas DC-9-32 on climbout from Dallas-Fort-Worth, December 12, 1995
Engine failure and evacuation, Airbus A319, November 2, 2001
Engine failure, Boeing 737-7H4, July 7, 1998
Contained engine failure, Douglas DC-9-82, June 25, 1999
Tread separation and engine failure, Airbus A300-B4-203, August 24, 1997
Birdstrike, Bombardier DHC-8-102, October 6, 1999
Engine fire, Airbus Industrie A300, July 9, 1998
Engine fire, Boeing 727-100, July 13, 2001
Engine fire, Douglas DC-6A, July 20, 1996
Engine fire, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, June 18, 1993
Engine fire, Boeing 757-232, April 17, 2003
Engine fire, Boeing 747-123, December 29, 2004
Birdstrike, rejected takeoff, and runway overrun, Boeing 737-200, Nashville, July 8, 1996
Birdstrike, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-82, September 16, 2004
Bird ingestion into both engines, Douglas DC-9-15F, March 4, 1999
Contained #2 engine failure, Boeing 727-232, August 14, 1996
Uncontained engine failure, Boeing 747-200, April 2, 2000
Tire tread separation and engine damage, McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10, March 24, 1998
Engine failure following birdstrike, Boeing 747-200, September 25, 1993
Birdstrike causing engine damage on a Boeing 737-300 at Portland, November 2, 1995
Runway excursion, Boeing 737-3G7, Kansas City, August 25, 2001
Overspeed And Loss Of Power On Both Engines During Descent And Power-Off Emergency Landing, Simmons Airlines, Inc., D/B/A American Eagle Flight 3641, N349SB False River Air Park, New Roads, Louisiana, February 1, 1994
Foreign object damage to engine, McDonnell Douglas DC-10, March 6, 2001
Bird ingestion and dual engine failure, Boeing 757, February 22, 1999
Foreign object ingestion and dual power loss, McDonnell Douglas DC-9-87, March 14, 1997
Dual engine failure and loss of directional control, Douglas DC-9-32, Windsor Locks, December 19, 1995
Foreign object damage to both engines, Boeing 737-200, March 20, 1996
Contained engine failure, Douglas DC-9-51, February 9, 1998
Smoke emergency and oil loss, Boeing 777, N796UA
Aircraft Accident Report, Explosive Decompression — Loss of cargo door in flight, United Airlines Flight 811, Boeing 747-122, N4713U, Honolulu, Hawaii, February 24, 1989
Rejected takeoff, Boeing 767-3YOER, ZS-PBI, London Gatwick Airport
Engine fire, Boeing 747-256, EC-DNP, August 11, 2002
Runway excursion, Royal Air Maroc Boeing 747-200 CN-RME, Dorval/Montreal International Airport, uebec, 23 July 2000

 




Accident Reports on DVD, Copyright © 2006 by Flight Simulation Systems, LLC.  All Rights Reserved.
 All referenced trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
www.fss.aero